PDA

View Full Version : Mario and Sonic, not a buy


Dragon Knight
4th December 2007, 10:10 PM
Mario and Sonic being together in a game was practically unheard of and people would think you were crazy if you were to say that this was really going to happen. Zoom to Mario and Sonic at the Olympic Games and we see two of the biggest icons in video game history compete for the gold. Under all that glamour and flash, it's just another mini game.


Most of the games you'll play are based off real life Olympic sports like the 100m relay race or the pole vault. You'll unlock more games as you play and eventually you will unlock dream games, events that put a magical spin on some events. The controls here will test your stamina as you are required to use the remote and/or the nunchuck in rapid, and sometimes jerking motions in order to play. This can easily tire you out if you play for too long and the game is not made to be played for hours without stopping. You'll really feel how sore your arms will be as you keep playing the game. While most of the controls are spot on, a handful of other games either have jerky or non responsive controls, making you very frustrated. Not only that, but most of the instructions on how to play are told through the controls menu before each game, which are made up of several pages. The manual is useless since it does not tell you how to play each game specifically.


The game has several modes, but its main beef consist of two modes; Single Match and Circuit. Single Match is a free play mode where you can pick any event and play it. Circuit mode is a series of events you play in while earning points based on your overall rank in each event, pretty similar to Mario Kart. What makes Single Match mode easy to set up is any number of players can join in before picking characters without having to do long set up. Mission mode is also like the mission mode in Mario Kart DS. Each character has different missions with specific requirements, like finishing a swimming race in 2nd place or beating Sonic in a relay race. Some are easy and some are tough.


The Gallery is where you can learn some real facts on how the Olympics works, but they are locked! To learn about the Olympics, you're forced to play some boring mini games like counting how many Goombas are on the screen or memorizing who spoke in what order, which don't end until you lose. This is also annoying since once you get past the goal requirement, you just don't want to keep playing unless you want to set a record for yourself.


There are 16 characters in the game. 8 from the Mario side and 8 from the Sonic side. Each character has different stats in Strength, Stamina, Speed, and Skill. Of course, each character excels in one particular stat so it's up to you to decide who is good in what. Even though Mario has a lower Speed rating than Sonic, it still baffles me how Mario could outrun sonic. You can even use your Miis as playable characters, but the downside is their stats are not shown and are randomized. Most of the catchphrases from the Mario characters have been rehashed from other games while the Sonic characters don't say a whole lot either, using the standard "I won," "I lost," or "That's me" lines. Sadly, there are no hidden characters.


The graphics seem to be at Gamecube level, something most Wii fans are a bit tired of seeing. The graphics don't "look" bad, but we've expected at least a step up in the graphics. The music is generic and is very forgettable, save for a few classic Mario and Sonic tunes you can listen to in the Gallery.

As you play the game, you can unlock achievement items like trophies and emblems for completing various things. They are for nothing but bragging rights. You can also use the achievements icons for your profile when you upload your records online.

While the boxart claims online support, it's actually gimped since the online feature is only used for leaderboard rankings and how you compare to people near your rank. Full online play would have been nice.


The game is pretty much, sadly, just another mini game. Good game with friends, and quickly gets boring alone. The dream events are fun to play, but sadly there are only 4. More dream events could have been used to make the game last a bit longer. Replay value is pretty minimal since there's not much to unlock and the events end very quickly. Tiring controls don't make the game playable for a long session and the online feature is useless. Rent if you can, but don't buy the game until a price drop.

cheat-master30
4th December 2007, 11:04 PM
Mario and Sonic being together in a game was practically unheard of and people would think you were crazy if you were to say that this was really going to happen. Zoom to Mario and Sonic at the Olympic Games and we see two of the biggest icons in video game history compete for the gold. Under all that glamour and flash, it's just another mini game.


Most of the games you'll play are based off real life Olympic sports like the 100m relay race or the pole vault. You'll unlock more games as you play and eventually you will unlock dream games, events that put a magical spin on some events. The controls here will test your stamina as you are required to use the remote and/or the nunchuck in rapid, and sometimes jerking motions in order to play. This can easily tire you out if you play for too long and the game is not made to be played for hours without stopping. You'll really feel how sore your arms will be as you keep playing the game. While most of the controls are spot on, a handful of other games either have jerky or non responsive controls, making you very frustrated. Not only that, but most of the instructions on how to play are told through the controls menu before each game, which are made up of several pages. The manual is useless since it does not tell you how to play each game specifically.


The game has several modes, but its main beef consist of two modes; Single Match and Circuit. Single Match is a free play mode where you can pick any event and play it. Circuit mode is a series of events you play in while earning points based on your overall rank in each event, pretty similar to Mario Kart. What makes Single Match mode easy to set up is any number of players can join in before picking characters without having to do long set up. Mission mode is also like the mission mode in Mario Kart DS. Each character has different missions with specific requirements, like finishing a swimming race in 2nd place or beating Sonic in a relay race. Some are easy and some are tough.


The Gallery is where you can learn some real facts on how the Olympics works, but they are locked! To learn about the Olympics, you're forced to play some boring mini games like counting how many Goombas are on the screen or memorizing who spoke in what order, which don't end until you lose. This is also annoying since once you get past the goal requirement, you just don't want to keep playing unless you want to set a record for yourself.


There are 16 characters in the game. 8 from the Mario side and 8 from the Sonic side. Each character has different stats in Strength, Stamina, Speed, and Skill. Of course, each character excels in one particular stat so it's up to you to decide who is good in what. Even though Mario has a lower Speed rating than Sonic, it still baffles me how Mario could outrun sonic. You can even use your Miis as playable characters, but the downside is their stats are not shown and are randomized. Most of the catchphrases from the Mario characters have been rehashed from other games while the Sonic characters don't say a whole lot either, using the standard "I won," "I lost," or "That's me" lines. Sadly, there are no hidden characters.


The graphics seem to be at Gamecube level, something most Wii fans are a bit tired of seeing. The graphics don't "look" bad, but we've expected at least a step up in the graphics. The music is generic and is very forgettable, save for a few classic Mario and Sonic tunes you can listen to in the Gallery.

As you play the game, you can unlock achievement items like trophies and emblems for completing various things. They are for nothing but bragging rights. You can also use the achievements icons for your profile when you upload your records online.

While the boxart claims online support, it's actually gimped since the online feature is only used for leaderboard rankings and how you compare to people near your rank. Full online play would have been nice.


The game is pretty much, sadly, just another mini game. Good game with friends, and quickly gets boring alone. The dream events are fun to play, but sadly there are only 4. More dream events could have been used to make the game last a bit longer. Replay value is pretty minimal since there's not much to unlock and the events end very quickly. Tiring controls don't make the game playable for a long session and the online feature is useless. Rent if you can, but don't buy the game until a price drop.

1. Haven't manuals always been totally useless? They've got worse since the times of the NES with full enemy guides and the like.

2. Why would that affect the score? It's only a minor thing, and I don't really think most gamers want to learn history (all I remember was something about The Olympics started in ancient Greece).

3. Meh. No hidden characters. They were also lacking from Mario Party though, and would this game be comparable to that series in a way?

4. Can't see much wrong with the graphics. Isn't the Wii at semi slightly higher than Gamecube quality? Or are these graphics just dull?

Dragon Knight
4th December 2007, 11:18 PM
The graphics just look like a port from the gamecube. If Mario Galaxy was able to push the graphic power further, I would hope other people could try it.


And no, manuals haven't always gotten worse. Most of the current gen games I own have full instructions. This manual doesn't even tell you the controls for each event.

cheat-master30
4th December 2007, 11:20 PM
About the manuals though, don't you miss the original NES type ones? All official art, full details of all enemies and bosses, full item information and even hints and tips for the game. I read one game came with a free strategy guide.

As for graphics, at least they beat this:

http://kotaku.com/gaming/no-no-no/cruisn-is-the-worst+looking-wii-game-ever-292534.php

Dragon Knight
4th December 2007, 11:33 PM
I don't have any NES manuals. Oldest ones I have are SNES. But even then, as long as they say how to play, I'm fine with it.

Symerwizkid22
5th December 2007, 12:12 AM
Nice review. Sounds like a very boring, and generic game. I too want to see more out of Wii's graphics. Super Mario Galaxy proved that the Wii's graphics can be good, if done correctly. Also, games that say they're online, but only have leaderboards, such as this one, really make me mad.

Let's hope both Mario and Sonic do a lot better in Super Smash Bros. Brawl.

Dragon Knight
5th December 2007, 12:25 AM
Oh i'm pretty sure mario and sonic in brawl will do very well. the game is looking like a success already.

account
5th December 2007, 12:26 AM
i think the title should be changed i mean what im saying is that you should make the conclusion more of a suprize.....

Symerwizkid22
5th December 2007, 12:37 AM
Oh i'm pretty sure mario and sonic in brawl will do very well. the game is looking like a success already.

I know, I was being sarcastic, as I think you already know. If SSB keeps up with it's predocessors, according to IGN, Brawl should be a 10.7! Lisreal

account
5th December 2007, 12:55 AM
Oh i'm pretty sure mario and sonic in brawl will do very well. the game is looking like a success already.

I know, I was being sarcastic, as I think you already know. If SSB keeps up with it's predocessors, according to IGN, Brawl should be a 10.7! Lisreal



give me that luigi head or die >:D

Dragon Knight
5th December 2007, 02:25 AM
i think the title should be changed i mean what im saying is that you should make the conclusion more of a suprize.....

I don't hold back anything in my reviews.

Symerwizkid22
5th December 2007, 02:34 AM
I don't either, except my titles are always just the name of the game and then the word 'review' after it.

account
5th December 2007, 02:48 AM
i think the title should be changed i mean what im saying is that you should make the conclusion more of a suprize.....

I don't hold back anything in my reviews.


yes perhaps in your review but not but the title is a diffrent issue.

Dragon Knight
5th December 2007, 02:10 PM
doesn't matter. people are going to read it no matter what. I don't need to keep people in suspense with the title.

blubomber17
5th December 2007, 04:51 PM
I agree. Let your opinion be known first, then support it and explain.

cheat-master30
5th December 2007, 04:55 PM
I really don't know which is better, opinion first or last. Seems to depend a lot on what exactly you are writing.

NintendudeCT
5th December 2007, 11:16 PM
I actually find this game fun. However, I always play it with friends or family. And you get alot of exercise from the Track games. I like games that make you move around alot. That's why I want to see a Wii Sports 2.:)

Sure, there isn't alot in it, but I would've been happy if the only characters in the game were your miis. I never use ingame characters.


I actually think it would've been better if it was just Wii Olympics, or something like that.